A Practitioner’s Guide to Vulnerability & Costs: Ensuring Access to Justice in Modern Civil Litigation & Beyond

Supporting vulnerable clients often requires additional time, skill and care. Longer conferences, adapted communications and practical adjustments can be essential to effective participation, But how should that work be identified, recorded, justified and paid for?

Drawing on almost 30 years’ experience in civil litigation and legal costs, Nick McDonnell provides a practical guide to understanding vulnerability and its financial consequences throughout the life of a case.

The book takes readers from recognising participation difficulties at the outset through to evidencing additional work and pursuing recovery of the resulting costs. It examines:

  • Identifying and managing vulnerability: recognising visible and hidden difficulties, adapting communication and responding to changing needs.
  • Recording and evidencing additional work: creating attendance notes and file records that explain what was required, why it was necessary and how vulnerability caused additional time or expense.
  • Solicitor–client costs: addressing retainers, funding arrangements, transparency, informed approval and assessment under the Solicitors Act 1974.
  • Costs recovery and proportionality: presenting vulnerability-related expenditure in context and responding to challenges at detailed assessment.
  • Fixed recoverable costs: examining the CPR 45.10 vulnerability gateway, its uncertainties, evidential requirements and associated costs risks.
  • Participation beyond litigation: considering vulnerability in settlement, mediation, complaints, tribunals and enforcement, alongside proposals for future reform.

Practical examples connect the legal framework with everyday decisions on a file. Throughout, the book emphasises that the strongest costs arguments are built as the case progresses, through careful identification, management and contemporaneous evidence.

Written for litigators, other legal professionals, judges and costs lawyers, the book explores a question at the heart of access to justice: when effective participation requires additional support, who bears its reasonable cost?

Find out more about the book at Law Brief Publishing